Your 5-Minute Email Storytelling Masterclass

by | Apr 23, 2024 | Copywriting | 0 comments

This post might contain affiliate links meaning we get a small commission if you choose to purchase through those links (without any extra cost to you). Read full disclosure here >>

I know you’re eager to turn your subscribers into loyal customers. You want those sales numbers to fly high.

But right now, a big struggle is holding you back.

You fill your emails with interesting information, educate your subscribers, and try to build a relationship by showing how much you know… yet you still feel unsatisfied with the response.

Why is that?

Well, here’s the blunt truth…

Informative content alone doesn’t truly connect with your readers. It doesn’t influence their beliefs or inspire action over the long term.

See, what people often forget is that facts open minds… but stories open hearts.

Now you might be wondering:

“What kind of ‘stories’ can I possibly tell about my SaaS or productivity coaching? Those topics aren’t very exciting…”

I get it. But compelling stories come in all shapes and sizes if you use strategic narratives.

These are stories engineered specifically to:

  • Guide your readers step-by-step from limiting beliefs to transformational new assumptions
  • Help them view your offers as the perfect solution for their evolving needs
  • Inspire loyal, high-value customers who stick around for the long haul

Think of it as reshaping beliefs through an emotional journey versus throwing boring facts at folks.

Make sense?

Over the next few minutes, I’ll break down exactly how to do that.

How to Craft Captivating Subscriber-Nurturing Stories

Alright, now that you know informative content misses the mark, let’s talk about how to craft email stories that truly captivate subscribers.

These strategic narratives reshape beliefs through four key ingredients:

A. Relatable characters
B. Immersive worlds
C. Strong narrative arcs
D. Belief-shaping plot

It’s storytelling specially engineered to guide your readers from limiting assumptions to seeing your solution as the perfect fit for their needs.

Let me break down each key ingredient:

A) Flawed Heroes Readers Love

First, you need a flawed protagonist at the centre of your story—an underdog dealing with a major problem related to an assumption currently holding your readers back.

This hero should be relatable and likeable despite their flaws. Someone who feels familiar from lived experience or pop culture. Maybe they grapple with self-doubt, money issues, or health challenges.

The point is to make readers think, “Hey, they seem like me…” and root passionately for the hero’s success.

There are three ways you can do this:

  1. Make yourself the hero
  2. Make a fictional hero resembling your target customers
  3. Make a past customer a hero

I personally don’t like the first method.

It can work really well if you’re selling your own experiences or learnings. But I prefer to use the other two because they work in 100% of the cases.

B) Obstacles That Feel Like Do-or-Die

Next, this is the world around the character.

Throw intense obstacles in your hero’s path related to those harmful assumptions readers share. Mountains that seem impossible to overcome.

Make it feel like an escalating do-or-die crisis with the highest stakes.

This crisis builds suspense and makes your later solution reveal feel like the glorious climax readers secretly hoped for.

C) Strong Narrative Arcs

This is what transforms your readers’ assumptions positively by guiding your underdog protagonist through a 3-phase emotional journey:

1) Introduce desire line

Early on, show your hero’s goal related to the limiting belief—perhaps financial freedom, better health, career growth, etc.

This plants the seed, making your later solution reveal feel like the perfect fit.

2) Escalate conflict

Throw increasingly intense crises and obstacles in their path related to false assumptions.

Show negative real-world impacts: lost relationships, financial ruin, and health declines. Make it truly seem hopeless.

3) Satisfying transformations

Here’s where the payoff comes:

Your solution helps the protagonist overcome limitations, resolve the crisis, and achieve their desire in an emotionally satisfying way.

Readers see firsthand how letting go of false beliefs and embracing your perspective unleashes game-changing success.

This climax shows them the power of transformed thinking on a gut level. And readies them to view your offers as the next logical step.

I use only this narrative arc for 90% of the narrative emails I write because this works best when it comes to selling through emails. So even if you master just this, you won’t need anything else.

D) Belief-shaping Plots

Challenge existing assumptions, transform beliefs, and make your solution irresistible.


1) Pinpoint blocking beliefs

First, use customer research to identify exactly which false assumptions may cause readers to resist your offers.

These often relate to credibility, safety, affordability, or efficacy in the solution or product area.

Common limiting beliefs include:

  • “Natural cures are unreliable”
  • “I could never start a business at my age”
  • “Weight loss systems don’t work long-term”

Whatever beliefs block buyers, shape characters and plots to systematically transform them.

2) Dismantle through emotional plots

Craft escalating story events challenging assumptions from multiple angles. Show protagonists stubbornly clinging to limiting beliefs even as negative real-world impacts multiply:

  • Failing health
  • Crumbling finances
  • Collapsing relationships

Pile on tension until finally reaching an agonising crisis climax caused by resistant thinking. This emotionally underscores the destructive danger of outdated assumptions.

3) Model evolved perspectives

Next, have your protagonist resolve escalating disasters by adopting the evolved perspective and assumptions your offers embody.

Show clear before/after contrast:

BEFORE (stubborn about assumptions): endless frustrating failure

AFTER (adopts your worldview): all dreams achieved at last!

This vividly demonstrates the empowering effects of new beliefs. Making your solution the logical next step.

Make sense?

You now hold incredible influence—the power to guide your readers from false assumptions towards new money-making beliefs…using strategically engineered narratives.

You just have to mix the ingredients, carve out a nice piece, and voila.

Look, I won’t sugarcoat it: Doing this well takes time and focused effort.

It has taken me YEARS of investing in experts, books, and trial & error.

You have to put in the work.

You must walk beside readers through falling action, rising hope, and finally a complete transformation towards seeing your solution clearly.

But with the right mixture of relatable heroes, escalating conflict, and belief-clarifying resolutions…

You CAN incrementally help audiences evolve outdated assumptions holding them back.

And make even the biggest sceptics increasingly eager to buy what you sell.

If you commit to serving readers with fiction-quality narratives, the rewards pour in:

  • Increased open & click rates
  • Surging sales from newly recruited loyal customers
  • Glowing reviews gushing about life-changing products/services

This goes way beyond informative content. It’s about opening hearts first, so receptive minds follow.

Now go WOW your dream buyers through magnetic stories that even Netflix would envy!

P.S. Always keep one thing in mind: never write fake stories. There’s a fine line between fiction and a fake story. Never cross that line. We move people with stories because we believe in truly helping them. We don’t manipulate or deceive.

Join The Email Fundamentals Newsletter for FREE. Learn how to write better emails with unique strategic frameworks and turn more email subscribers into paying customers. With only one power-packed email per week. Every Tuesday. 

(No daily spam or jargon… just pure value!)

Rahul Choudhary

Rahul Choudhary

Founder, Beef Up Media

With almost 6 whole years of experience in the online marketing world & specialising in email marketing + funnels, I’ve seen most – the good, the bad, and the downright ugly.

My goal?

Try to share as much of my knowledge & experience as possible.

Don’t forget to connect with me on social media. ↓

related posts:

How to Use the A-B Narrative to Write Emails That Convert 30% More

How to Use the A-B Narrative to Write Emails That Convert 30% More

Are you always looking for shortcuts to write money-making emails? Get this straight: No fancy templates, overused power words and overly salesy nonsense are going to help you sell your offers. What we’ve found common in emails that drive sales through the roof? → A...

IERD Framework For Writing High-converting Email Copy

IERD Framework For Writing High-converting Email Copy

Sending out email after email and getting minimal response is frustrating, isn't it? Here’s a disgustingly disappointing stat: Only 20% of marketing emails get opened. And from those, a mere fraction of clicks. And a bunch of sales, if you’re lucky. That's not only...

Use These 5 Framing Techniques For Your Next Email

Use These 5 Framing Techniques For Your Next Email

I get it. You want more sales and conversions from your emails. But constantly hitting that send button and hoping for the best isn't working. Crickets in your inbox when you expected $$$ is beyond frustrating. What stings the most is seeing a competitor smashing it...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *